“Helping a couple start their
family was one of the most rewarding
experiences of my life…”
- Surrogate Leah H

How to Choose a Surrogacy Agency: A Guide for Surrogates

Surrogacy offers an extraordinary opportunity to make an impact. Whether you’re matched with an LGBTIQA+ couple, a single parent by choice or a couple facing fertility challenges, you’ll be helping others achieve their dream of having a child. 

The decision to become a gestational surrogate is a profoundly personal one. However, this process also involves legal, financial and medical aspects, so relying on a trusted surrogate agency is essential. From matching you with the Intended Parents to handling all legalities with care, your agency is there to ensure your journey is both well-protected and fulfilling. To help you choose the right partner, let’s explore the most important factors to consider and questions to ask.

Key Qualities of a Trusted Surrogacy Agency

Finding a trustworthy and reliable surrogacy agency starts with carefully researching your options. As you explore different agencies, here’s what to look for to help you make the best choice. 

A Proven Track Record

Experience speaks volumes when choosing a surrogate agency. With the global surrogacy industry expected to reach $129 billion by 2032, new agencies will continue to emerge. Look for one with a proven track record of facilitating successful surrogacy journeys, backed by client testimonials

With years of experience, the best agencies have streamlined processes to make your experience as stress-free as possible. They’ll also often have team members with personal connections to surrogacy who can offer a genuine understanding and knowledgeable support every step of the way. 

A Focus on Communication

The surrogacy process may be new territory for you, so a communicative agency is essential. Choose a partner that sets clear expectations, explains the necessary qualifications, and provides clear information about costs and compensation. 

Trust begins with transparency, and the right agency will prioritize open dialogue and welcome any questions. This creates the foundation for a partnership in which you feel confident, heard and supported. 

An In-House Legal Team

Legal expertise is crucial, as surrogacy laws vary by state and demand careful navigation. Your surrogate agency should have a qualified legal team that understands the necessary regulations and can guide you appropriately. 

In-house legal professionals can ensure smooth communication and proper handling of contracts. Beyond providing legal support, a reliable agency will require independent representation for both Intended Parents and surrogates. This way, you have peace of mind that everyone’s rights and interests are protected. 

An Emphasis on Relationships

Understanding how an agency approaches relationships between Intended Parents and surrogates says a lot about their values. Relationship-focused agencies prioritize building a special bond between both parties, enriching their experience together. With such an approach, agencies listen carefully to both sides to ensure matches feel natural and authentic. 

What Surrogates Need Most: Support and Emotional Care

Your path as a surrogate deserves respect, compassion and complete support at every turn. However, not all agencies provide the same level of care. For example, some surrogacy programs focus solely on matching surrogates with Intended Parents. 

Full-service agencies offer more comprehensive services, including legal guidance, fertility care, and ongoing resources and emotional support throughout the process. They’re dedicated to making you feel comfortable, appreciated and cared for at every milestone, from conception to post-birth. 

Since you’ll likely partner with your surrogate agency for a year or more, you owe it to yourself to find the perfect fit. Before you commit, take time to understand their complete service offerings. 

5 Questions to Ask Before Choosing a Surrogacy Agency

Asking questions is the best way to find an agency that aligns with your expectations and values. A supportive partner will welcome your curiosity and provide the information you need to feel comfortable. Their transparency can give you the confidence to entrust them with your decision to give the incredible gift of parenthood. 

Here are five questions to ask a surrogacy agency​.

1. What Support Do You Offer Surrogates?

Your chosen agency should have dedicated resources to help you navigate any challenges, from support groups to counseling services. This care should continue after the baby is delivered. Complete post-birth support is a must and involves finalizing all procedural matters while offering continued access to legal and emotional counseling. Such a support system can help you feel secure from your initial meeting to the months following the delivery.

2. What Are Your Compensation and Benefits Policies?

Although becoming a surrogate is a heartfelt gift to the Intended Parents, you should still be well-compensated for your time and dedication. Financial transparency is vital — you have a right to know exactly what your financial package includes and which expenses are covered.

A trustworthy agency will be upfront about which payments and benefits are part of your base fee versus which are additional. This clarity can ensure you feel secure and valued, allowing you to embrace this remarkable journey without any financial surprises.

3. How Are Surrogates Matched With Intended Parents?

The connection between a surrogate and the Intended Parents is at the heart of a rewarding experience. When exploring different agencies, look for a thorough, personalized matching process that ensures compatibility. 

This process often includes comprehensive questionnaires, interviews, and facilitated calls and meetups to help you find the right fit. Both parties should be aligned on communication preferences, expectations and values. 

4. How Do You Ensure Legal and Ethical Compliance?

Surrogacy is guided by intricate legal agreements designed to safeguard the rights of everyone involved — you as the surrogate, the Intended Parents, and any sperm or egg donors. Understanding how surrogate agencies uphold ethical and legal requirements is essential. 

Potential partners should be able to explain the legal frameworks they adhere to and how they protect you and the other parties. As discussed, this typically includes offering robust legal support, such as drafting the Gestational Carrier Agreement, ensuring it complies with state laws and resolving any potential issues.

5. What Is Your Experience and Success Rate?

A surrogate agency that is willing to be open about its success rates is a good sign. High rates usually mean that you’ll be in expert hands. Don’t hesitate to ask for specifics, including live birth rates and the satisfaction of past surrogates. Trustworthy partners will proudly share this information, giving you the affirmation needed for a stress-free and positive journey toward the beautiful outcome you had hoped for. 

Choose The Center for Surrogacy & Egg Donation for Your Journey

Egg Donation Blog

Read the latest blog posts for Donors

Surrogacy Blog

Read the latest blog posts for Surrogates

Intended Parents Blog

Read the latest blog posts for Intended Parents

Related Articles

How Does Surrogacy Work?

Surrogacy is a life-changing experience that allows you to give the gift of family to those who need help building theirs. At The Center for Surrogacy

Read More »

Egg Donation Blog

Read the latest blog posts for Donors

Surrogacy Blog

Read the latest blog posts for Surrogates

Intended Parents Blog

Read the latest blog posts for Intended Parents